Tax Reform Bill Seeks to Transform Executive Compensation, Eliminate Tax-Favored Treatment for Key Employee Benefit Programs
The long-awaited Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, released by the House Ways and Means Committee on November 2, 2017, contains significant changes to the taxation of executive compensation and eliminates tax-favored treatment for several employee benefit programs that are popular with employees. Here is a high-level summary of the proposed changes: 1. Elimination of deferred compensation; 2. Nonqualified stock options no longer viable; 3. Public companies lose deductions on executive compensation; 4. New excise tax on tax-exempt employer executive compensation. The bill eliminates the tax-favored treatment of several employee benefit programs: 1. Pre-tax benefits under a dependent care flexible spending account or a dependent care assistance program (that is employer funded) would be eliminated. 2. Tuition reimbursement plans would no longer be tax-favored (currently, employers can provide pre-tax tuition assistance to employees of up to $5,250 a year). 3. Transportation fringe benefit plans, adoption assistance plans, qualified moving-expense reimbursement arrangements, employee achievement awards, and Archer medical savings accounts, would no longer be eligible for pre-tax treatment.
Highest Earners at Tax-Exempt Hospitals Face new Tax on Compensation under GOP Plan
The Republican tax reform bill released Nov. 2 proposes a new excise tax on compensation that would affect executive teams at tax-exempt hospitals. The legislation would also repeal the performance-based exception to the $1 million limit on deductible compensation. Right now, businesses can write up to $1 million in compensation expenses for the five highest earners in the company as well as any amount beyond that $1 million that is tied to performance targets. The GOP proposal will retain that $1 million threshold, but public companies would no longer be able to deduct annual performance-based compensation in excess of $1 million for the CEO, CFO and top three highest-paid employees.
Primary Care, Specialty Physician Salaries Remain Stagnant
Anecdotally, physician career coaches report that physician salaries are flat at best. They have observed a downward trend for physicians' incomes, especially for specialties that have traditionally been well-paying, such as radiology. Primary care physicians, such as pediatricians and obstetricians, have not seen salary increases. Some physicians, even specialists, have been seeking nonclinical revenue sources to supplement their income. Changing compensation structures have hurt, not helped, the bottom line for most doctors. Physicians' salaries do not advance with seniority but rather based on production.
Health IT Salaries Fell 20% in 2017 even as Executive Compensation Surged
On average, health IT professionals made just over $73,000 in 2017, a 20% decline from the previous year, according to survey data published by Health eCareers. The company, which connects healthcare employers with job seekers, surveyed nearly 20,000 professionals in the healthcare provider industry ranging from clinical staff to executives. Informatics professionals were the hardest hit. Out of 724 survey respondents that identified themselves as health IT professionals, more than half indicated they worked specifically in healthcare informatics and data where the median salary was $46,000 annually, nearly $30,000 less than last year. There are a couple explanations for declining salaries. This year's survey included fewer IT executives, which are by far the highest-paid group. Their absence drags down the average. But part of that decline may also be attributed to hospitals and health systems paring back their use of consultants and hiring full-time staff at a cheaper price, according to Mike Silverstein, managing partner of healthcare IT and life sciences at Direct Recruiters Inc. in Solon, Ohio. Most health systems have implemented an EHR and don't need high-priced consultants to walk them through a complicated rollout.
Use Salary Survey Data with Caution during Physician Compensation Negotiations
How much does the average neurologist make? Is it almost $315,000? Or less than $250,000? It depends on which salary survey you look at, which is why doctors should use those compensation reports with caution when trying to determine whether they are fairly compensated, according to the American Academy of Neurology. The salary surveys can be helpful in giving physicians a general sense of what other doctors in their field make and how much money they should ask for, but the numbers vary depending on how the surveys are done, which can result in vastly different results. Take in all this information you see -- and take it with a grain of salt. Use it as a guidepost, but don't expect things to go well if you're trying to make a hard-and-fast decision based on what's black and white on a salary survey somewhere. And keep in mind that some colleagues in the same specialty will earn more money than the average doctor, such as those with "rockstar status" who can attract new patients and increase an organization's prestige or those who take on leadership roles.
Forecasting the 'Perfect Storm' of Compensation and Collections
For medical groups and integrated health systems, a perfect storm is gathering. While medical group costs -- including compensation -- continue to rise, productivity and collections are generally flat, according to AMGA's 2017 Medical Group Compensation and Productivity Survey. These trends are driving enhanced efficiency and consolidation, but the cost curve will only bend so much. Absent pricing power, medical groups are likely to recalibrate compensation for select specialties. The report, based on a survey of 269 medical groups representing more than 102,000 providers, shows that: Compensation rose for 77% of the 140 physician specialties AMGA tracks. The overall weighted average increase in median compensation was 2.9% for 2016, similar to the 3.1% increase in 2015. At the same time, 51% of the physician specialties reported a decrease in their median net collections in 2016. Net collections represent the actual dollar amount collected for professional activities after all discounts from gross charges are applied. These trends help explain the drive among health systems to enhance efficiency, in part through the mergers and acquisitions sweeping through markets across the country. These measures, however, can only bend the cost curve so much, and because physician compensation is a major cost center, many systems are facing added pressure to raise prices or curb compensation.
A look at long-term trends related to heart and vascular specialties illustrates the squeeze created by compensation and collections:
The picture is similar, but not quite as dire in the orthopedic specialties:
SAVE THE DATES
Featured ASHHRA Webinar: Essentials for a Successful Lean Recruitment Transformation Journey in Health Care
Unique Approaches to Laying the Cultural Groundwork
Thursday, November 30, 2017
12:00-1:00 p.m. CT
Presented by AHA Health Forum For the past eight years, Lean Human Capital has conducted the Healthcare Recruitment Benchmark Study and recognizes health care recruitment organizations that are performing at an "Elite" level with respect to productivity, process efficiency, responsiveness and quality. This recognition is called the Lean Human Capital Elite Honor Roll. Join us as Dana Cates, senior consultant at Lean Human Capital, reviews the 2017 benchmark study highlights and trends. She will also share her own experience as a health care practitioner and former Lean Human Capital Elite winner as she talks about her transformation journey. In addition, Dana will speak with one of this year's Lean Human Capital Elite Honor Roll recipients, Shana Welch, regional director, Talent Acquisition at Mercy Health and Saint Joseph Mercy Health System, to share its transformation journey and what the organization is doing with respect to recruitment performance. Speakers: Dana Cates, Sr. Consultant, Lean Human Capital by HealthcareSource and Shana Welch, SHRM-SCP, Regional Director, Talent Acquisition, Mercy Health and Saint Joseph Mercy Health System.
Featured Archived PayScale Webinar: Communicating Pay to Employees
A recent PayScale study revealed that employees' perceptions of how they are paid are a better predictor of their intent to stay than their actual fair pay to the market. These implications create a huge opportunity for employers to get it right when it comes to communicating pay effectively. Conversations about pay are often perceived as scary, demoralizing, or just boring. However done right, pay talk can actually be quite motivating. Join compensation experts Mykkah Herner and Paige Hanley as they explore: Why is talking about pay with employees so important; How can you train your managers to have useful compensation conversations; What are some typical situations you may encounter when it's time to talk pay